BREANNE CHIZUE CONTRERAS (HUNTERSVILLE) – By Consent, the Commission reprimanded Ms. Contreras, effective May 30, 2022. The Commission found that Ms. Contreras acted as the listing agent for a residential property where she and her husband owned the LLC seller. Buyer 1 went under contract to purchase the subject property and had a home inspection performed. Buyer 1 shared the summary of the home inspection report with Ms. Contreras, but ultimately terminated during the due diligence period when his closing attorney notified him of a potential set-back issue. Ms. Contreras failed to fully disclose these material facts to Buyer 2 who went under contract to purchase the subject property and had a home inspection performed. Buyer 2’s home inspection noted some of the same issues as buyer 1’s home inspection report. Buyer 2 closed on the subject property after agreeing to a Due Diligence Request and Agreement with Ms. Contreras.
RICARDO ALBERTO CONTRERAS JR (HUNTERSVILLE) – By Consent, the Commission reprimanded Mr. Contreras, effective May 30, 2022. The Commission found that Mr. Contreras purchased residential property through his LLC and pulled permits for an interior renovation. Although the electrical and plumbing permits were completed, the building permit status still showed “Not Finaled” [sic] on the county website. Buyer 1 went under contract to purchase the subject property, but terminated during the due diligence period when his closing attorney notified him of a potential set-back issue. Buyer 2 went under contract a month later and Mr. Contreras did not disclose the permit status nor did he disclose the potential set-back issue raised by the previous closing attorney, basing his decision not to do so on legal advice from other attorneys. Buyer 2 closed on the subject property without issue. The city zoning office advised Commission staff that a zoning violation still existed, but that it may be cured with the approval of an administrative deviation.
KRISTA MARIE CUTLER (CHARLOTTE) – By Consent, the Commission reprimanded the broker license of Ms. Cutler, effective June 20, 2022. The Commission found that in June 2019, Ms. Cutler was the broker-in-charge of the listing agent for the sale of a residential property. The individual listing agent failed to verify the property’s septic permit and advertised the property as having four bedrooms when the septic permit specified three bedrooms. The listing agent has entered into a settlement with the 2019 buyer to the buyer’s satisfaction and the buyer has now sold the property.
ELISE MARIE FREDERICH (RALEIGH) – By Consent, the Commission suspended the broker license of Elise Marie Frederich for a period of 12 months, effective June 10, 2022. The Commission then stayed the suspension in its entirety. The Commission found that Ms. Frederich, acting as the broker-in-charge of Sensational Realty Inc., failed to properly account for trust money and comingled funds resulting in an apparent overage in the firm’s trust account.
FOUND REALTY LLC (HUNTERSVILLE) – By Consent, the Commission reprimanded Found Realty LLC, effective May 30, 2022. The Commission found that Found Realty LLC acted as the listing firm for a residential property with Breanne Contreras acting as its broker-in-charge. Ms. Contreras and her husband owned the LLC seller. Buyer 1 went under contract to purchase the subject property and had a home inspection performed. Buyer 1 shared the summary of the home inspection report with Ms. Contreras, but ultimately terminated during the due diligence period when his closing attorney notified him of a potential set-back issue. Ms. Contreras failed to fully disclose these material facts to Buyer 2 who went under contract to purchase the subject property and had a home inspection performed. Buyer 2’s home inspection noted some of the same issues as buyer 1’s home inspection report. Buyer 2 closed on the subject property after agreeing to a Due Diligence Request and Agreement with the Ms. Contreras.
SANDRA GOOCH HOLLIS (RALEIGH) – By Consent, the Commission reprimanded Ms. Hollis, effective June 7, 2022. The Commission found that Ms. Hollis acted as a listing agent for the sale of her client’s home and undertook to represent them as their buyer agent in a residential purchase transaction. Ms. Hollis was aware that her client needed to use the proceeds from the sale of their current home in order to purchase their new home. Ms. Hollis, acting as a buyer agent, submitted an offer to purchase on behalf of her client and failed to have them execute an addendum to make the purchase conditioned upon the sale of her client’s current home. Instead, Ms. Hollis entered a due diligence expiration date in the contract that occurred thirty-nine (39) days after the proposed closing date. Ms. Hollis failed to notice that the executed contract she received back from the listing agent had a different due diligence expiration date, which was initialed by the seller, thus creating a counter offer. Ms. Hollis’ client subsequently issued due diligence and earnest money deposit funds and proceeded with a home inspection. The issues of whether or not a valid contract existed and the proper ownership of the Earnest Money Deposit remain in dispute between the buyer and seller.
BARBARA LYNN KATLEN (TROUTMAN) – By Consent, the Commission suspended the broker license of Barbara Lynn Katlen for a period of 6 months, effective June 10, 2022. The Commission then stayed the suspension in its entirety. The Commission found that in June 2021, Ms. Katlen acted as the listing agent for a seller-client. Just three months prior, Ms. Katlen had acted as the seller-client’s buyer’s agent for the same subject property. During the initial purchase of the subject property in March 2021, a home inspection revealed certain deficiencies in the crawl space while the crawl space was in the process of being encapsulated and remediated by the seller. Ms. Katlen confirmed no repairs were made by the sellers during their ownership and failed to disclose the crawl space issue noted in the March 2021 inspection report. An inspection conducted in July 2021 by the complaining witness buyer revealed a crawl space deficiency that had been noted in the March 2021 inspection report when Ms. Katlen acted as the buyer’s agent.
LIFESTYLE HOMES OF DISTINCTION (ASHEVILLE) – By Consent, the Commission suspended the firm license of Lifestyle Homes of Distinction for a period of 12 months, effective June 15, 2022. The Commission then stayed the suspension in its entirety. The Commission found that Lifestyle Homes of Distinction, also licensed by the NC Licensing Board for General Contractors (NCLB-GC), failed to report that, by Consent Order dated 10/21/2020, they were disciplined by the NCLB-GC. Pursuant to the Consent Order, Lifestyle Homes of Distinction’s BIC was suspended for one year with three months active, ordered to pay a $5000 fine, and ordered to complete two courses.
R VARATHARAJU M RAMAN (CHARLOTTE) – By Consent, the Commission reprimanded R Varatharaju M Raman, effective June 10, 2022. The Commission found that Mr. Raman listed a property for sale, which he had purchased and renovated through his company. Mr. Raman failed to ensure that the required permits were pulled during the renovations. Buyer 1 went under contract to purchase the subject property and had a home inspection performed. Buyer 1 then terminated the transaction after sending a copy of their home inspection report to Mr. Raman. Mr. Raman did not make any repairs or update the property disclosure form prior to re-listing the subject property. Buyer 2 then went under contract to purchase the subject property and had a home inspection performed which revealed some of the same issues as Buyer 1’s report. Mr. Raman and Buyer 2 agreed on repairs and Buyer 2 successfully closed on the subject property. Mr. Raman failed to disclose the lack of permits to Buyer 1 and 2 at the time their offers were made and failed to disclose outstanding material issues to Buyer 2 that were discovered during Buyer 1’s inspection.
KIMBERLY A MOORE-DUDLEY (GREENSBORO) – By Consent, the Commission reprimanded Ms. Moore-Dudley, effective June 10, 2022. The Commission found that from May 15, 2019 – July 16, 2021, Ms. Moore-Dudley was broker-in-charge of a firm. In early 2021, Ms. Moore-Dudley became aware that an unlicensed LLC was receiving compensation through the firm by payment from the market center administrator. Ms. Moore-Dudley informed the market center administrator that only licensed entities could receive compensation for brokerage activities and informed the broker at issue in that scenario to properly license the LLC. Upon investigation, it was learned that additional unlicensed entities were being paid for brokerage activity at the time Ms. Moore-Dudley was broker-in-charge of the firm.
EUGENE GERARD PITZER (RALEIGH) – By Consent, the Commission reprimanded Mr. Pitzer, effective June 10, 2022. The Commission found that Mr. Pitzer entered into a listing agreement with a seller-client who disclosed that the property was part of an inheritance and, therefore, had multiple heirs who would need to agree to the sale. Mr. Pitzer relied on the seller’s representations that the other heirs had agreed to the sale, and failed to discover and disclose additional heirs who were necessary parties to the contract. A contract to buy the property was terminated when the seller was unable to get all heirs to sign off and the buyer lost $8000 in due diligence fees paid that the seller had spent during the pendency of the contract. The Commission noted that Mr. Pitzer had reimbursed the buyers for their due diligence fees and additional costs incurred.
SENSATIONAL REALTY INC (RALEIGH) – By Consent, the Commission suspended the firm license of Sensational Realty Inc. for a period of 12 months, effective June 10, 2022. The Commission then stayed the suspension in its entirety. The Commission found that Sensational Realty Inc. failed to properly account for trust money and comingled funds resulting in an apparent overage in its trust account.
JAMES COOPER SMITH (RALEIGH) – By Consent, the Commission suspended the broker license of James Cooper Smith for a period of 6 months, effective June 10, 2022. The Commission then stayed the suspension in its entirety. The Commission found that Mr. Smith purchased a residential property and received a home inspection report provided by the seller. Mr. Smith closed on the subject property and made substantial repairs to it over the next few months with various contractors. Mr. Smith listed his property with a licensed firm and failed to ensure that all of the repairs made to the subject property corrected all of the material issues discovered by the previous inspection report. The home inspection reports of future buyers discovered some of the same issues as noted on the prior inspection report. The Commission notes that Mr. Smith has since corrected these issues and the home has sold.
The sudden death or incapacity of a Broker-in-charge or Qualifying Broker can change things in an instant. What happens when the Broker-in-charge or Qualifying Broker becomes incapacitated or even dies? That depends on whether or not the Broker-in-charge (“BIC”) or Qualifying Broker (“QB”) has a Succession Plan in place.
According to a North Carolina broker who recently went through this situation, the transition can be CHAOS! You think there is always time but, suddenly, “Tom” and other brokers at the firm were thrust into a situation where they had a brokerage without a BIC/QB and without a plan. Tom’s advice to all is to have a plan in place long before you think you need one. Whether a Sole Proprietor, LLC, or Corporation, a Succession Plan is a must.
Commission Rule 58A.0512 addresses what can be done when the BIC who is a sole proprietor dies or becomes incapacitated. Upon receipt of a written notification and certified copy of a court order appointing an executor, administrator or fiduciary, the Commission can issue a temporary license, valid for one year, to the BIC’s administrator. This temporary license allows the administrator to handle the distribution of trust money held and commissions owed to the BIC/sole proprietor at the time of the BIC’s death or incapacity. But remember that this is only to wrap up the business, and to allow final disbursements. Existing listings, sales contracts, or property management agreements must be transferred to a new broker.
There is so much more to be handled and so much more to consider. What if this is not a sole proprietor but a licensed firm or a sole proprietorship with multiple affiliated brokers? What if the firm/sole proprietorship wants to continue conducting brokerage activity? In order to continue conducting brokerage activity, a new BIC (and possibly QB) still needs to be designated. Has anyone even considered who that would be and if that person is eligible to hold BIC or QB status? And will that new BIC and/or QB have all of the information needed to run the business? Will the new BIC and/or QB know where to find or have access to trust and business accounts, agency agreements, and all other information necessary to continue to run the business?
Similar to having a written firm policy and procedures manual, a Succession Plan can ensure a smooth transition in the event of an unforeseen loss. You may consider having a broker or two in training to be the new BIC, not just in the situations of death or illness, but in the event you take that extended vacation you have been dreaming about. You might consider who your firm’s qualifying broker is. Is this the same person as the BIC? Should the QB and BIC be the same person? Is there someone else who can step up as QB if a replacement is also needed?
This article is full of questions for you to consider, but you provide the answers. The bottom line is, it is your business, your plan and your decision – IF you plan ahead. Consult an attorney and accountant and decide what is best for you and your situation. Be prepared. No one wants to think of a situation where they are injured, incapacitated or pass away but if you face these possibilities early, you help your loved ones, business associates, and clients in both dealing with loss and moving forward smoothly and with as little disruption as possible.
Stephen L. Fussell, Chief CPO
In an effort to gain a competitive advantage, some prospective buyers may ask their agents to include escalation clauses in their offers. An escalation clause is one in which a prospective buyer expresses their willingness to pay a specific amount more than the highest competing buyer. The escalation clause may or may not indicate a maximum amount that the prospective buyer is willing to pay.
The Commission discourages the use of escalation clauses. Commission Rule A .0115 reads as follows: “A broker shall not disclose the price or other material terms contained in a party’s offer to purchase, sell, lease, rent, or to option real property to a competing party without the express authority of the offering party.” How does this rule impact escalation clauses? Assume, for example, that Buyer #1 offers to pay $1,000 more than any other offeror. In order to establish the price that Buyer #1 will pay, the brokers involved would have to share the terms of the highest offer with Buyer #1. Sharing these terms is prohibited except in the unlikely event that the other buyer consents to it.
Pitfalls of escalation clauses:
A seller’s best response in a multiple offer situation where one or more of the buyers is using an escalation clause will likely be to invite all buyers to make their highest and best offers. That way, each buyer is given an opportunity to buy the property at the price and terms they are willing to pay and the seller will receive the best offer from each buyer rather than an incremental offer from a buyer who wants to offer slightly more than a competing buyer.
Escalation clauses tend to focus on price. Listing agents should exercise care to advise seller-clients to consider more than the sales price in an offer. An offer from a well-qualified buyer who offers a lesser amount may be a wiser choice than a higher offer from a less-qualified buyer. Similarly, an offer from a buyer who has visited the property may be preferred over one who offers a high price sight unseen.
Brokers who choose to use escalation clauses should proceed with extreme caution. Real estate transactions are complex even without such clauses. Real estate transactions in busy markets with low inventory can be even more frantic. Escalation clauses may introduce confusion, anxiety, frustration and fraud. For these reasons, the Commission discourages their use.
Have you ever wanted to attend a Real Estate Commission meeting to see what happens? If so, please join us at the Have you ever wanted to attend a Real Estate Commission meeting to see what happens? If so, please join us at the JB Duke Hotel, 230 Science Drive, Durham, NC, in Meeting Room C at 9 a.m. You are welcome to stay for a portion or for all of the Commission’s meeting. Mark your calendars for July 20!
CESAR AUGUSTO OSORIO (ARDEN) – The Commission accepted the voluntary surrender of the broker license of Cesar Osorio effective May 18, 2022. The Commission dismissed without prejudice allegations that Mr. Osorio violated provisions of the Real Estate License Law and Commission rules. Mr. Osorio neither admitted nor denied misconduct.
Sheryl Graham, Consumer Protection Officer, spoke at the REMAX United office meeting on May 17.
Steve Fussell, Chief Consumer Protection Officer, spoke at the Showcase Realty LLC meeting on May 18.
Shanna Hardy, Consumer Protection Officer, spoke at the REMAX Leading Edge office meeting on May 25.
Are you interested in joining the staff of the North Carolina Real Estate Commission? From time to time, employment opportunities become available. They are posted on the Commission’s website under the “About Us” tab.
We currently have opportunities available for the following positions:
Director of Education and Licensing
Auditor – Application Deadline June 28, 2022
Consumer Protection Officer – Application Deadline June 27, 2022
Network Administrator – Application deadline July 5, 2022
Click here for more information.
The Commission’s auditors visit brokers-in-charge throughout the state to perform spot audits of trust accounts. This case is an example of why brokers-in-charge are now required by Rule A.0110 to take the Basic Trust Account Course within 120 days of assuming responsibility for a trust account (but no more than every three years). In the spot audit of a real estate firm that performed both sales and long term property management, the auditor found multiple areas of concern. Unfortunately, the broker-in-charge had been making mistakes in their trust account recordkeeping for so long that it was impossible to determine exactly how much of the money in the trust account belonged to which owner. Being able to identify exactly whose money is in the bank is a primary reason for the trust accounting rules – A.0116, A.0117, and A.0118.
The Ledger Problem:
The first problem the broker-in-charge had was that the software used for the property management accounting created ledgers where rent was treated like an accounts receivable, meaning that at the beginning of the month the rent populated as being due from the tenant. This is perfectly fine for tenant ledgers and tracking outstanding balances. However, Rule A .0117(c)(4) also requires that property or owner ledgers be maintained, and this firm did not have either. Property or owner ledgers should show the exact amount of money on hand, at any given time, for a particular property or owner. The problem with ledgers that populate an amount due is that, if the tenant does not pay their rent for that month or multiple months, there is a balance on the ledger that is an outstanding amount owed by the tenant when the ledger should indicate the amount of money on hand for the owner.
Sometimes when ledgers do not exist or are unclear, auditors use owner statements as a substitute, which is what we attempted to do on this audit. In this case, many owner statements had negative balances. Negative balance owner statements indicate that the expenses exceeded the income for that particular owner. When more money is spent on a property than the owner has in the trust account, it usually means that another owner/client has just paid those expenses. This is one form of deficit spending.
The Journal Problem:
Deposits and withdrawals on the ledgers and owner statements should be traceable to a journal. A journal is a check register where all deposits and withdrawals in a trust account are recorded. In this case, a journal was maintained but individual entries were not recorded. Instead, one amount was entered for all deposits on one day and another lump sum entry was made for all the withdrawals. There was no way to trace deposits or withdrawals on the journal to the ledgers or to confirm that all the journal entries were being posted.
The Reconciliation Problem:
In addition, there was no way to reconcile to the journal, which meant that the required three-way reconciliations were not being performed. The bank statements were not being reconciled against the journal because there was no way to confirm that the journal was accurate. The journal was not reconciled against the trial balance because no trial balance was maintained.
A trial balance is the sum of all of the ledgers at a set cutoff date, usually the same date as the bank statement. If a property management firm represents fifty owners, then every month the balance of each of those fifty owner ledgers should be totaled. This total should match, exactly, the reconciled bank balance and journal balance. In this case, since there were no owner or property ledgers, a trial balance could not be produced.
The Shortage Problem:
A true trial balance could not be created from the owner statements because of all the negative balances. Using the owner statements, even with the negative balances, it showed that the property management trust account had a significant shortage.
As seen in this case, failure to maintain trust account records properly at any stage in the process can have a domino effect. The auditor found other more minor infractions in addition to the major problems. The firm was given an opportunity to correct the deficiencies but they were unsuccessful in bringing the trust account into compliance and, therefore, received a disciplinary sanction. Trust account problems and shortages do not necessarily stem from theft or evil intent. A shortage can result if the broker-in-charge is not taking the necessary steps to maintain records. If any of the above sounds familiar (or unfamiliar) and you maintain a trust account, then take the trust account course and start to work on fixing your trust account records. It is only a matter of time before an auditor from the Commission will be knocking on your door.
Are you interested in joining the staff of the North Carolina Real Estate Commission? From time to time, employment opportunities become available. They are posted on the Commission’s website under the “About Us” tab.
We currently have available the following position:
Director of Education and Licensing is currently available at the Commission’s office in Raleigh. A summary of the position and other employment opportunities are available on the Commission’s website. – Application deadline May 12, 2022.
Click here for more information.
Sheryl Graham, Consumer Protection Officer, spoke at the HTR Southern Properties office meeting on April 5.
Janet Thoren, Director of Regulatory Affairs, spoke at the Lantern Realty and Development LLC meeting on April 13.
Bruce Rinne, Information Officer, spoke at the United Real Estate-Queen City meeting on April 26.
Miriam Baer, ExecutiveDirector of NC Real Estate Commission, spoke at the Pointe Realty Group sales meeting on April 27.
Janet Thoren, Director of Regulatory Affairs, spoke at the Outer Banks Association of REALTORS General Membership meeting on April 28.