Bulletin Search

Disciplinary Actions

CHARLOTTE BAUGHER (Raleigh) – The Commission accepted the voluntary surrender of the broker license of Ms. Baugher effective March 17, 2021. The Commission dismissed without prejudice allegations that Ms. Baugher violated provisions of the Real Estate License Law and Commission rules. Ms. Baugher neither admitted nor denied misconduct.

YU PEI CHOOI (Cary) – The Commission accepted the voluntary surrender of the broker license of Ms. Chooi effective April 21, 2021. The Commission dismissed without prejudice allegations that Ms. Chooi violated provisions of the Real Estate License Law and Commission rules. Ms. Chooi neither admitted nor denied misconduct.

C MILLER PROPERTIES INC. (Hickory) – The Commission accepted the voluntary surrender of the firm license of C. Miller Properties effective March 17, 2021. The Commission dismissed without prejudice allegations that C. Miller Properties violated provisions of the Real Estate License Law and Commission rules. C. Miller Properties neither admitted nor denied misconduct.

GATEWAY REALTY SERVICES (Cary) – The Commission accepted the voluntary surrender of the firm license of Gateway Realty Services effective April 21, 2021. The Commission dismissed without prejudice allegations that Gateway Realty Services violated provisions of the Real Estate License Law and Commission rules. Gateway Realty Services neither admitted nor denied misconduct.

ROBERT C. MILLER (Hickory) – The Commission accepted the voluntary surrender of the broker license of Mr. Miller effective March 17, 2021. The Commission dismissed without prejudice allegations that Mr.  Miller violated provisions of the Real Estate License Law and Commission rules. Mr. Miller neither admitted nor denied misconduct.

SANDRA C. MOORE (Hickory) – The Commission accepted the voluntary surrender of the broker license of Ms. Moore effective March 17, 2021. The Commission dismissed without prejudice allegations that Ms. Moore violated provisions of the Real Estate License Law and Commission rules. Ms. Moore neither admitted nor denied misconduct.

ANNA M. PAPP (Cary) – The Commission accepted the voluntary surrender of the broker license of Ms. Papp effective March 17, 2021. The Commission dismissed without prejudice allegations that Ms. Papp violated provisions of the Real Estate License Law and Commission rules. Ms. Papp neither admitted nor denied misconduct.

BEVERLY D. OSBORNE (Rock Hill, SC) – Following a hearing, the Commission permanently revoked the broker license of Ms. Osborne effective March 16, 2021. The Commission found that Ms. Osborne failed to self-report her South Carolina real estate license revocation and to communicate with Commission staff.

GROVER F SHUGART JR (Winston Salem) – The Commission accepted the voluntary surrender of the broker license of Mr. Shugart Jr. effective March 17, 2021. The Commission dismissed without prejudice allegations that Mr. Shugart violated provisions of the Real Estate License Law and Commission rules. Mr. Shugart neither admitted nor denied misconduct.

SHUGART MANAGEMENT (Winston Salem) – The Commission accepted the voluntary surrender of the firm license of Shugart Management effective March 17, 2021. The Commission dismissed without prejudice allegations that Shugart Management violated provisions of the Real Estate License Law and Commission rules. Shugart Management neither admitted nor denied misconduct.

OLUREMILAKUR WILLIAMS (Raleigh) – The Commission accepted the voluntary surrender of the broker license of Mr. Williams effective April 21, 2021. The Commission dismissed without prejudice allegations that Mr. Williams violated provisions of the Real Estate License Law and Commission rules. Mr. Williams neither admitted nor denied misconduct.

NEW Working With Real Estate Agents Disclosure Is Available

In January 2020, the Consumer Federation of America (“CFA”) published a report entitled, “Why Required Real Estate Agent Disclosures about Representation Fail and How They Can Be Improved.” The report contains a list of recommendations for improving agency disclosure forms.

The Commission’s Working With Real Estate Agents brochure has been used for approximately 25 years. Although it contains good information, changes in technology, communication methods, and the faster pace of real estate transactions have made its format less user friendly.

The Commission has created a new disclosure form (“Working With Real Estate Agents Disclosure”) which will make agency disclosure quicker and easier for brokers and more understandable for buyers and sellers. The form is just two pages in length, with one page dedicated to sellers and one page dedicated to buyers. A broker explaining agency to a seller need only review the seller side of the form; likewise, a broker disclosing agency relationships to a buyer need only review the buyer side.

The new form replaces the old Working With Real Estate Agents brochure as the form that brokers must review with prospective buyers and sellers at first substantial contact. The new disclosure form is now available on the Commission’s website (ncrec.gov) under the “PUBLICATIONS” tab.

The Commission encourages brokers to begin using the form immediately. Effective 7/1/21, brokers will be required to use this form in all commercial and residential sales transactions.

On 4/26/21, the Commission hosted a 60-minute webinar introducing this new form. A recording of the webinar is available for viewing on the Commission’s website.

This form will be translated into Spanish and will be discussed in the 2021-2022 GENUP and BICUP courses. Aside from the introduction of this new form, there has been no change to the rule which requires agency disclosure (A .0104(c)) and no change in the types of agency relationships that brokers may offer. The only change is in the form that brokers use to explain agency relationships.

How Do I Love Thee . . . Send the Love Letters to A Sweetheart, Not A Seller

Today’s market is HOT!  Really HOT.  Like a cheap romance novel HOT.  Sellers are receiving an enormous amount of attention, with multiple buyers wooing them for their homes by offering prices well over list, large due diligence fees, and yes, love letters.

Who is encouraging these love letters designed to pull at the heartstrings of the seller and lull them into accepting a particular buyer’s offer over others?  Usually the buyer agent.  Maybe the buyer has heard the letter is needed from family or friends trying to help out.  The bottom line is such letters can create a problem and are best avoided by all.

The purpose of a “love letter” is simple enough – a buyer wants to be the chosen one, and it seems reasonable enough to attempt to win their dream home by pouring out their hearts to the sellers.  However, these letters can pose serious fair housing risks as they usually contain personal information about the buyers which may result in conscious or unconscious bias in selection by the sellers. 

What does that mean?  Let’s say the buyers include a photograph or two of themselves.  Now the seller is looking at the buyers and can see their race, whether or not they have children (familial status), or whether or not they are heterosexual.    The buyers may refer to how they can’t wait to put up a Christmas tree by the fireplace – an indication of their religious beliefs.  All of these things about the buyers may form the basis of selection by the sellers.  These factors go beyond the price and terms of an offer.  The sellers may make their choice – consciously or unconsciously – based on facts about the buyers’ race, familial status or religion, all of which are protected categories under fair housing laws. 

If you are the listing agent, you should educate your sellers about the pitfalls of love letters – this type of letter opens them up to criticism and possibly to civil liability and they should not look at such letters even if they are sent directly to the sellers from the buyers.  Sellers should only be considering offers based on objective criteria – price and terms.  Your firm may have a policy against the use of such letters – if so, let your clients know that if you receive such a letter with an offer you will not be passing it on to them.   NAR recommends that no such letters be accepted as part of an MLS listing.  Document the reasons your client chose or rejected each offer.

If you are a buyer agent, your firm may also have a policy against the use of such letters.  Never recommend that a buyer prepare a love letter for the seller or tell the buyer to send such a letter directly to the sellers.  Let your buyers know the market is hot, and they should make their highest and best offer if they want to be successful.  Prepare them for the fact that, in an extremely competitive market, they will likely lose a number of properties before they find the home that was meant to be theirs. 

The key here is to protect your clients from possible harm by removing the temptation to go with a contract simply because photographs or letters tug at their hearts and instead have them choose the best offer on the table.  Love may be blind, but unconscious bias is real and sees clearly.  Keep your clients and yourself safe from any potential fair housing issues.

Disciplinary Actions

KRISTINE YATES BOURGEOIS (RALEIGH) – By Consent, the Commission reprimanded Ms. Bourgeois effective March 10, 2021. The Commission found that Respondent acted as the buyer’s agent in the purchase of residential real property. After going under contract, the listing agent sent Ms. Bourgeois a text stating “new main water line will be installed due to slow leak somewhere in the main line.” Ms. Bourgeois failed to confirm that the water line was replaced prior to closing. The subject property closed without the water line being replaced. 

JOHN CARL CARMENATE (BURLINGTON) – By Consent, the Commission reprimanded Mr. Carmenate effective March 10, 2021. The Commission found that Mr. Carmenate, acting as the qualifying broker and broker-in-charge of a firm, failed to renew the Firm’s license with the Commission and failed to keep its Certificate of Authority active with the Secretary of State. Following expiration of the Firm’s license, Mr. Carmenate continued to manage properties in North Carolina and failed to respond to Letters of Inquiry and other communications from Commission staff.

STEPHANNIE ANNETH CHESLEY (MOORESVILLE) – By Consent, the Commission reprimanded Ms. Chesley effective March 10, 2021. The Commission found that Ms. Chesley acted as a co-listing agent for residential real property. The first buyer (“Buyer 1”) terminated the contract after having a home inspection performed. This inspection report was given to Ms. Chesley and noted certain material issues throughout the home. She took the home off the market while the sellers had their insurance company fix the leak in the kitchen and make extensive repairs to that area of the home as well as the crawlspace then placed the property back on the market and it went under contract with another buyer (“Buyer 2”). Buyer 2’s home inspection revealed some of the same material issues noted in Buyer 1’s inspection report. Buyer 2 terminated the contract and gave a copy of their inspection report to Ms. Chesley. The sellers addressed some, but not all, of the material issues noted in Buyer 2’s inspection report. Ms. Chesley placed the property back on the market and a few days later, it was under contract with another buyer (“Buyer 3”). Buyer 3 terminated before the end of the due diligence period and did not provide a copy of their inspection report to Ms. Chesley. She then placed the property back on the market and a few weeks later, it was under contract with another buyer (“Buyer 4”) who ultimately purchased it. Ms. Chesley failed to disclose the material issues noted on previous home inspection reports or other inspections performed, not corrected by the sellers, to Buyer 2, Buyer 3, and Buyer 4 or their agents at the time the offers were made. Ms. Chesley failed to advise her seller-clients to update their original answers on the property disclosure form.

MENATALLA EFFAT (CHARLOTTE) – The Commission accepted the voluntary surrender of the broker license of Ms. Effat effective February 17, 2021. The Commission dismissed without prejudice allegations that Ms. Effat violated provisions of the Real Estate License Law and Commission rules. Ms. Effat neither admitted nor denied misconduct.

JENNIFER PEARL GALLAGHER (RALEIGH) – By Consent, the Commission suspended the broker license of Ms. Gallagher for a period of twelve (12) months effective January 31, 2021. The Commission required the first sixty (60) days to be active and stayed the remainder of the suspension effective April 1, 2021, and placed Ms. Gallagher on probation until January 30, 2022. The Commission found that Ms. Gallagher was showing a residential property to her buyer-client and entered the subject property prior to her buyer-client arriving. A camera inside the subject property captured Ms. Gallagher consuming alcohol from some of the property owner’s bottles. Ms. Gallagher later sent a letter of apology to the property owner and has replaced the bottles. The Commission notes that Ms. Gallagher is remorseful for her actions.

STANLEY B MARTIN (HIGH POINT) – By Consent, the Commission reprimanded Mr. Martin effective March 9, 2021. The Commission found that in May 2018, Mr. Martin acting as the qualifying broker and the broker-in-charge for a firm, misrepresented the square footage for a property he listed. Mr. Martin listed the property as having 2,150 square feet. In fact, the property was only 1,590 square feet, a difference of approximately 36%.

LANE FRANKLIN MCKINNEY (MOORESVILLE) – By Consent, the Commission reprimanded Mr. McKinney effective March 10, 2021. The Commission found that Mr. McKinney acted as a co-listing agent for residential real property. The first buyer (“Buyer 1”) terminated the contract after having a home inspection performed. This inspection report was given to the co-listing agent and noted certain material issues throughout the home. The home was taken off the market while the sellers had their insurance company fix the leak in the kitchen and make extensive repairs to that area of the home as well as the crawlspace then the property was placed back on the market and it went under contract with another buyer (“Buyer 2”). Buyer 2’s home inspection revealed some of the same material issues noted in Buyer 1’s inspection report. Buyer 2 terminated the contract and gave a copy of their inspection report to the co-listing agent. The sellers addressed some, but not all, of the material issues noted in Buyer 2’s inspection report.  The property was placed back on the market and a few days later, it was under contract with another buyer (“Buyer 3”). Buyer 3 terminated before the end of the due diligence period and did not provide a copy of their inspection report to Mr. McKinney. The property was then placed back on the market and a few weeks later, it was under contract with another buyer (“Buyer 4”) who ultimately purchased it. Mr. McKinney failed to disclose the material issues noted on previous home inspection reports or other inspections performed, not corrected by the sellers, to Buyer 2, Buyer 3, and Buyer 4 or their agents at the time the offers were made. Mr. McKinney failed to advise his seller-clients to update their original answers on the property disclosure form.

TIFFANY ADAMS MYERS (FAYETTEVILLE) – The Commission accepted the permanent voluntary surrender of the broker license of Ms. Adams Myers effective February 17, 2021. The Commission dismissed without prejudice allegations that Ms. Adams Myers violated provisions of the Real Estate License Law and Commission rules. Ms. Adams Myers neither admitted nor denied misconduct.

NRT CAROLINAS LLC (CHARLOTTE) – By Consent, the Commission reprimanded NRT Carolinas LLC effective February 17, 2021. The Commission found that the acting broker-in-charge (“BIC”) failed to supervise two provisional brokers (“PB’s”) who acted as co-listing agents where they failed to ensure that their seller-clients had either repaired all material items identified on home inspection reports or updated their answers on the property disclosure form. The PB’s also failed to disclose any remaining material items to buyers at the time offers were made. The Commission notes that Respondent has updated their policy manual to include increased supervision and training of PB’s.

PIEDMONT REALTORS LLC (HIGH POINT) – By Consent, the Commission reprimanded Piedmont Realtors LLC effective March 9, 2021. The Commission found that in and May 2018, the firm misrepresented the square footage for a property it listed. Piedmont Realtors LLC listed the property as having 2,150 square feet. In fact, the property was only 1,590 square feet, a difference of approximately 36%.

RIVER WALK PROPERTIES (HAW RIVER) – The Commission accepted the permanent voluntary surrender of the broker license of River Walk Properties effective February 17, 2021. The Commission dismissed without prejudice allegations that River Walk Properties violated provisions of the Real Estate License Law and Commission rules. River Walk Properties neither admitted nor denied misconduct.

VICKI SMITH STOWE (WILMINGTON) – By Consent, the Commission reprimanded Ms. Stowe effective March 10, 2021. The Commission found that Ms. Stowe acted as the listing agent in a residential transaction where the seller had a home inspection performed prior to listing the property for sale, a copy of which was given to her. This inspection revealed material issues with the property. No repairs were made to the property and the RPOAD was completed by the seller with no issues noted. A few months later, Buyer #1 went under contract to purchase the subject property and had a home inspection performed. Ms. Stowe failed to disclose all material issues to Buyer #1. Similar material issues were noted on Buyer #1’s inspection report as were noted on the pre-listing inspection report and a copy of Buyer #1’s report was given to Ms. Stowe. Buyer #1 later terminated the contract. The seller addressed some, but not all, material issues noted in the previous inspection reports such as issues with the HVAC system and electrical. The next month, Buyer #2 went under contract to purchase the subject property and had a home inspection performed. Ms. Stowe failed to disclose all material issues to Buyer #2. Similar material issues were noted on Buyer #2’s inspection report as were noted on Buyer #1’s inspection report and the pre-listing inspection report. Buyer #2 terminated the contract and a copy of his inspection report was given to Ms. Stowe.  

THE KEY GROUP ENTERPRISES INC. (FAYETTEVILLE) – The Commission accepted the permanent voluntary surrender of the broker license of The Key Group Enterprises Inc. effective February 17, 2021. The Commission dismissed without prejudice allegations that The Key Group Enterprises Inc. violated provisions of the Real Estate License Law and Commission rules. The Key Group Enterprises Inc. neither admitted nor denied misconduct.

Appearances

Peter Myers, Information Officer, spoke at NC Best Practices Meeting on March 10.

Danielle Alston, Consumer Protection Officer, spoke at FM Realty Sales Meeting on March 16.

Fred Moreno, Chief Deputy Legal Counsel, spoke at the Materiality of Nearby Concentrated Animal Feeding Operations discussion on March 19.

Dee Bigelow, Consumer Protection Officer, spoke at the URE-QC Presents – Straight Talk with the NCREC on March 30.

The Pitfalls of Using Escalation Clauses

By Stephen L. Fussell, Chief CPO

In an effort to gain a competitive advantage, some prospective buyers may ask their agents to include escalation clauses in their offers.  An escalation clause is one in which a prospective buyer expresses their willingness to pay a specific amount more than the highest competing buyer. The escalation clause may or may not indicate a maximum amount that the prospective buyer is willing to pay.

The Commission discourages the use of escalation clauses, but does not prohibit them.  Commission Rule A .0115 reads as follows: “A broker shall not disclose the price or other material terms contained in a party’s offer to purchase, sell, lease, rent, or to option real property to a competing party without the express authority of the offering party.” Therefore, in the unlikely event that a buyer consents to allow a broker to share the price and terms specified in their offer with another prospective buyer, then and only then may the broker do so.

Pitfalls of escalation clauses:

              A seller’s best response in a multiple offer situation where one or more of the buyers is using an escalation clause will likely be to invite all buyers to make their highest and best offers.  That way, each buyer is given an opportunity to buy the property at the price and terms he or she is willing to pay and the seller will receive the best offer from each buyer rather than an incremental offer from a buyer who wants to offer slightly more than a competing buyer.

            Escalation clauses tend to focus on price.  Listing agents should exercise care to advise seller-clients to consider more than the sales price in an offer.  An offer from a well-qualified buyer who offers a lesser amount may be a wiser choice than a higher offer from a less-qualified buyer. Similarly, an offer from a buyer who has visited the property may be preferred over one who offers a high price sight unseen.

            Brokers who choose to use escalation clauses should proceed with extreme caution.  Real estate transactions are complex even without such clauses. Real estate transactions in busy markets with low inventory can be even more frantic. The use of such clauses may introduce confusion, anxiety, frustration and fraud.  For these reasons, the Commission discourages their usage and the disclosure of the terms of competing offers even when authorized by buyers.

Current Stats: Total Disciplinary Cases as of February 28, 2021

Note: To enlarge this image, adjust the Zoom settings in your browser window.

Disciplinary Actions

MICHAEL ANTHONY BOWMAN (CHARLOTTE) – The Commission accepted the voluntary surrender of the broker license of Mr. Bowman effective February 1, 2021. The Commission dismissed without prejudice allegations that Mr. Bowman violated provisions of the Real Estate License Law and Commission rules. Mr. Bowman neither admitted nor denied misconduct.

BOWMAN REAL ESTATE LLC (CHARLOTTE) – The Commission accepted the voluntary surrender of the broker license of Bowman Real Estate LLC effective February 1, 2021. The Commission dismissed without prejudice allegations that Bowman Real Estate LLC violated provisions of the Real Estate License Law and Commission rules. Bowman Real Estate LLC neither admitted nor denied misconduct.

EMSLEY A. LANEY, III (WILMINGTON) – Following a hearing, the Commission permanently revoked the broker license of Mr. Laney effective December 31, 2020. The Commission found that Mr. Laney failed to maintain and retain trust account records. Mr. Laney also failed to safeguard and account for trust monies resulting in trust account shortages.

LANEY REAL ESTATE CO. (WILMINGTON) – Following a hearing, the Commission permanently revoked the firm license of Laney Real Estate CO. effective December 31, 2020. The Commission found that Laney Real Estate CO failed to maintain and retain trust account records. Laney Real Estate CO also failed to safeguard and account for trust monies resulting in trust account shortages.

DAVID MOSELEY PROCTOR (KINSTON) – By Consent, the Commission permanently revoked the broker license of Mr. Proctor effective January 15, 2021. The Commission found that Mr. Proctor failed to enter into an agency agreement with a buyer-client prior to submitting an offer to the seller. Mr. Proctor also failed to enter into an agency agreement before representing a seller-client. Mr. Proctor misrepresented to his seller-clients that his buyer-client did not want to purchase a second lot from the sellers. Mr. Proctor’s misrepresentation induced his seller-clients to sell the lot to him for $1.

CARMEN WHITLEY SHAW (NORTH MYRTLE BEACH) – By Consent, the Commission reprimanded Ms. Shaw effective January 1, 2021. The Commission found that Ms. Shaw, whose license has been on inactive status since July 1, 2016, was employed as an administrative assistant at a firm. In July, 2020, Ms. Shaw’s broker-in-charge made an appointment to show a property in Carolina Shores, NC, which included in the MLS that “Sellers require everyone entering home to wear mask and gloves” due to COVID-19. Instead of the broker-in-charge, Ms. Shaw showed the property to potential buyers, who were members of her family, and, while at the subject property, did not follow the directive of the seller that that masks and gloves needed to be worn at all times.

TEAM ANDERSON REALTY (HOLLY SPRINGS) – By Consent, the Commission reprimanded Team Anderson Realty effective February 1, 2021. The Commission found that the firm falsely advertised the square footage of a home in the MLS when the affiliated listing agent included a basement area with no heat source in the living area, contrary to the professional measurer’s description.

Appearances

Sheryl Graham, Consumer Protection Officer, spoke at HomeTown Realty’s Brokers Office Meeting on February 25.

Homeowner Protection Extensions

On February 16, 2021, the White House announced the following extensions of COVID-19 protections for homeowners:

Homeowners and renters can visit consumerfinance.gov/housing for more information on relief options.

The announcement is available at: 

https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2021/02/16/fact-sheet-biden-administration-announces-extension-of-covid-19-forbearance-and-foreclosure-protections-for-homeowners/