Bulletin Search
Disciplinary Actions
TIARA NICOLE COX (GRAHAM) – By Consent, the Commission suspended the broker license of Cox for a period of 9 months, effective November 30, 2024. The Commission then stayed the suspension in its entirety upon certain conditions. The Commission found that Cox commingled funds; disbursed trust money for a client which exceeded the balance for that client; applied trust money to a purpose for which it was not intended; did not maintain records sufficient to verify the accuracy of trust funds; did not keep separate ledgers for each rental property; did not keep a general journal; and did not reconcile the trust account monthly.
CREB INC (MOORESVILLE) – The Commission accepted the permanent voluntary surrender of the real estate firm license of Creb Inc, effective November 13, 2024. The Commission dismissed without prejudice allegations that Creb violated provisions of the Real Estate License Law and Commission Rules. Creb neither admitted nor denied misconduct.
HUEY REAL ESTATE (GRAHAM) – By Consent, the Commission suspended the real estate firm license of Huey Real Estate for a period of 9 months, effective November 30, 2024. The Commission then stayed the suspension in its entirety upon certain conditions. The Commission found that Huey Real Estate commingled funds; disbursed trust money for a client which exceeded the balance for that client; applied trust money to a purpose for which it was not intended; did not maintain records sufficient to verify the accuracy of trust funds; did not keep separate ledgers for each rental property; did not keep a general journal; and did not reconcile its trust account monthly.
LINDA J HUTAFF (PINEHURST) – By Consent, the Commission reprimanded Hutaff effective November 13, 2024. The Commission found that Hutaff received a lead for listing a vacant lot from the believed owners (“Fraudster”). Fraudster told Hutaff he knew a former client of Hutaff. Hutaff failed to obtain any proof of identification from Fraudster, such as a driver license, passport, ID card, etc. Fraudster provided Hutaff with the true owners’ names and out-of-state address, and Hutaff conducted a social media search and verified the County Tax Public Records including confirming the information on the deed of record. Thereafter, Hutaff prepared the listing for the property and emailed the listing documents to Fraudster for his electronic signature. Hutaff then listed the property on the Multiple Listing Service and placed a sale sign on the property. After the property was listed, Fraudster accepted an offer of $189,000 with a 14-day closing and signed the offer contract electronically. The executed contract was mailed to the closing attorney and Hutaff’s assistant mailed the $6,000 due diligence check to the owner’s address of record in Virginia. After closing and wiring payment for the property, it was discovered Fraudster was not the true owner.
DONELL J KEITH (ABERDEEN) – By Consent, the Commission suspended the broker license of Keith for a period of 24 months, effective September 16, 2024. The Commission then stayed the suspension in its entirety upon certain conditions. The Commission found that Keith acted as listing agent for an investor selling a residential property they had renovated. The seller disclosed to Keith that a chimney fire had caused damage, and that they had documents evidencing that an engineer had recommended a repair method, and that the damage had been repaired. Keith did not obtain or review the seller’s documents and failed to disclose the fire to potential buyers. A buyer purchased the property and discovered after closing that there had been a fire. The Commission noted that Keith has entered a settlement with the buyer that includes having a contractor complete additional repairs to the buyer’s satisfaction.
JOHNNY W MITCHELL (RALEIGH) – By Consent, the Commission suspended the broker license of Mitchell for a period of 4 years, effective September 16, 2024. The Commission then stayed the suspension following a 2-month active period upon certain conditions. The Commission found that Mitchell acted as a buyer’s agent for a buyer-client who went under contract to purchase residential property. The Multiple Listing Service (“MLS”) agent remarks noted that a road widening project could affect the property and included a North Carolina Department of Transportation (“NCDOT”) link for further information. After the initial showing, the listing agent contacted Respondent to ask whether the road project affected his client’s interest in the property. Mitchell replied to the message “a little, but not much” although Mitchell had failed to disclose the project to his client. Mitchell’s buyer-client purchased the property and subsequently learned of the road project plans which could require the NCDOT to purchase the property in the next 3-5 years. The Commission noted that Mitchell has reached a confidential settlement with the buyer-client to the client’s satisfaction.
MOUNTAIN PARTNERS LLC (HENDERSONVILLE) – By Consent, the Commission reprimanded Mountain Partners LLC effective November 13, 2024. The Commission found that in or about April 2023, an affiliated broker of Mountain Partners LLC who is also a Respondent in this case acted as the listing agent for a property. Respondents listed the property on the Multiple Listing Service (“MLS”) and classified the property’s construction type as an on-frame modular. The property later went under contract with a buyer. On or about June 13, 2023, the buyer agent provided the listing agent proof of a Housing and Urban Development (“HUD”) tag located on the property during the appraisal, a Manufactured Home Certification confirming that the property was a manufactured home, and a copy of the owner’s 2023 General Warranty Deed for the property which referenced a “Declaration of Intent to Affix Manufactured Home to Real Property,” recorded in 2011, which matched the data plate on the property. On or about June 27, 2023, Respondents modified the property’s construction classification in the MLS listing from on-frame modular to manufactured, on-frame modular. Subsequently, the buyer terminated the contract. On or about July 5, 2023, Respondents relisted the property in MLS and one public remark stated, “[t]he house has been remodeled, and there is [no] HUD number, according to county records is ON-FRAME modular.” On or about July 7, 2023, the property MLS listing was again modified to change the classification from manufactured, on-frame modular back to on-frame modular. Mountain Partners LLC failed to ensure the listing for the property was accurate in its initial listing, relisting, and modifications.
MV REALTY OF NORTH CAROLINA LLC (RALEIGH) – Following a hearing, the Commission permanently revoked the broker license of MV Realty effective July 11, 2024. The Commission found that MV Realty solicited homeowners to sign Homeowner Benefit Agreements binding the owners and their heirs to a forty-year term to list their property with MV, and barred the transfer or refinancing of their property without MV Realty’s authorization. The Commission found that MV Realty brokers failed to provide and review the Working with Real Estate Agents Disclosure with prospective sellers; made false promises, misrepresentations, and omissions to prospective sellers regarding Homeowner Benefit Agreements and listing agreements; failed to timely deliver documents and agreements to consumers, engaged in improper, fraudulent, and dishonest dealing in the offering of Homeowner Benefit Agreements; and acted in an incompetent or unworthy manner when acting as a listing agent in real estate transactions.
BRANDON C NARRON (WILSON) – The Commission accepted the voluntary surrender of the real estate broker license of Narron, effective November 13, 2024, with no right to reapply for two years. The Commission dismissed without prejudice allegations that Narron violated provisions of the Real Estate License Law and Commission Rules. Narron neither admitted nor denied misconduct.
NARRON SELLS INC. (WILSON) – The Commission accepted the voluntary surrender of the real estate firm license of Narron Sells Inc., effective November 13, 2024, with no right to reapply for two years. The Commission dismissed without prejudice allegations that Narron Sells Inc. violated provisions of the Real Estate License Law and Commission Rules. Narron Sells Inc. neither admitted nor denied misconduct.
KAYLA H ROGERS (DURHAM) – By Consent, the Commission suspended the broker license of Rogers for a period of 2 years, effective May 1, 2024. The Commission then stayed the suspension following a 6-month active period upon certain conditions. The Commission found that Rogers was the seller of a home she owned and failed to disclose potential septic and foundation issues to the listing agent or the buyer. Rogers had previously stated in a public video that the septic system had been damaged by construction trucks and blasting on a nearby lot. Following the purchase, the buyer discovered that septic system issues discussed with Rogers, through her agent, were more extensive than disclosed.
WANDA R TATE (OCEAN ISLE BEACH) – By Consent, the Commission suspended the broker license of Tate for a period of 9 months, effective November 13, 2024. The Commission found that Tate was the broker-in-charge for a vacation rental management firm. Tate failed to maintain a property ledger and could not produce a trial balance for managed properties. Tate maintained monthly owner statements that did not present a running balance of funds on the accounts. Revenue and management fees were incorrectly reported. Tate improperly collected and paid expenses from the operating account instead of the trust account.
THEODORUS C PRETORIUS (MOORESVILLE) – The Commission accepted the permanent voluntary surrender of the real estate license of Pretorius, effective November 13, 2024. The Commission dismissed without prejudice allegations that Pretorius violated provisions of the Real Estate License Law and Commission Rules. Pretorius neither admitted nor denied misconduct.
TRACEY B SMITH (SNEADS FERRY) – The Commission accepted the permanent voluntary surrender of the real estate broker license of Smith, effective November 13, 2024. The Commission dismissed without prejudice allegations that Smith violated provisions of the Real Estate License Law and Commission Rules. Smith neither admitted nor denied misconduct.
Beyond Discipline: Your Path Forward
The Final Part of an in-depth Five-Part series on the Complaint and Disciplinary Process in Regulatory Affairs. See Part One “Navigating Complaints: A How-To Guide” from the August 2024 eBulletin, Part Two “The Road Ahead: After the Investigation” from the September 2024 eBulletin, Part Three “Beneath the Surface: The Pre-Hearing Process” from the October 2024 eBulletin, and Part Four “Inside the Hearing Room: A Closer Look” from the November 2024 eBulletin.
After a disciplinary action has been ordered or approved by the Commission, whether following a hearing or entering into a Consent Order, the Respondent receives a fully executed copy of the final order of the Commission. An order may include a conditional disciplinary sanction that requires a compliance review by Commission staff. During this phase, the focus is on ensuring that the Respondent has complied with any and all terms and conditions set by the Commission by the stated deadline.
A common term and condition of an order requires a Respondent to complete certain real estate education courses. No continuing education credit is earned for the completion of courses used to satisfy a disciplinary order by the Commission. A Respondent may be required to complete the Commission’s Issues and Answers in NC Real Estate Practice Courses. This Course is in high demand and only offered approximately six times per year at the Commission’s offices in Raleigh. The Course is taught by Commission staff and fills up quickly. It is advised to sign-up as soon as possible to ensure compliance by the stated deadline. Other education course requirements may focus on topics such as material facts, agency, or square footage. For information concerning approved education providers, schedules, and locations, a Respondent may consult the continuing education schedule posted on the Real Estate Commission’s website.
All terms and conditions must be completed by the stated deadline in the Order. If a Respondent fails to meet the terms and conditions stated in the Order, the disciplinary sanction prescribed in the Order will immediately and automatically become effective on the date stated in the Order. If a Respondent meets all terms and conditions of the Order, the conditional sanction stated in the Order becomes effective and the Respondent receives a Conditional Disciplinary Action Compliance Report (“Compliance Report”) stating the final sanction. The Compliance Report also contains important information regarding next steps including any applicable license reinstatement fees and activation requirements. The Commission prints a summary of its disciplinary actions in its online publication, the Real Estate eBulletin, which is distributed electronically to each licensee. If you have questions about the Disciplinary Process, please call the Regulatory Affairs Division at (919) 719-9180.
Self-Dealing vs. Fiduciary
Brokers must act as fiduciaries for their principals while conducting real estate transactions. A “fiduciary” is a person who acts for another in a relationship of trust and who is obligated to act in the other’s best interests, placing the other’s interests before any self-interest.
Video Link: https://youtu.be/cvVHrtHdbNU
Commission Presentations
November 2024 Presentations
Sarah Dixon, Associate Legal Counsel II, spoke at OWN Real Estate on November 7th.
Bruce Rinne, Information Officer, spoke at Allen Tate REALTORS® on November 8th.
December 2024 Presentations
*These presentations are subject to change due to the availability of Commission members and/or staff.*
Bruce Rinne, Information Officer, will speak at Lifestyle International Realty on December 3rd.
Bruce Rinne, Information Officer, will speak at BHHS Carolinas Realty on December 4th.
Miriam Baer, Executive Director, will speak at Land of the Sky Association of REALTORS® on December 18th.
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Article
December 3rd is International Day of Persons with Disabilities.
This international observance, promoted by the United Nations since 1992, is a day aimed at raising awareness and promoting the rights and well-being of persons with disabilities. While there are laws, such as the Americans with Disabilities Act and the Fair Housing Act, which prohibit discrimination against those with a disability, as a real estate professional you should work to create an inclusive environment for the consumers and communities you serve.
With over 32% of North Carolinians identifying as having a disability, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s Disability and Health Data System, the Commission hopes that you would consider ways to better serve those with disabilities.
Linked below are resources to help educate you on the rights of those with disabilities as well as resources to help you navigate successfully serving those with disabilities.
Americans With Disabilities Act (ADA)
Civil Rights Division | The Fair Housing Act
Disability Main | HUD.gov / U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD)
Disability Overview | HUD.gov / U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD)
Disability — Fair Housing Project
Fair-Housing-and-Disability-Brochure-10-8-2018.pdf
Home Ownership Matters – How REALTORS® Can Help Disabled Homebuyers
5 Tips For Working With Clients Who Have Disabilities – NC REALTORS®
Reminder: December is HERE! Have you reinstated your license?
Brokers with an expired license are required to cease all brokerage activities from the date of license expiration, i.e., July 1. But the good news for those who didn’t mean to allow their license to expire is that they have until December 31st to reinstate their license without additional education requirements. The bad news? December 31 is coming up fast. If the license isn’t reinstated by then, it will be too late to reinstate without additional steps.
What steps must a broker take to reinstate an expired license? That answer depends on how long the license has been expired.
To reinstate a license expired for less than 6 months:
- Go to the Commission’s homepage (www.ncrec.gov);
- Click on Reinstate your License;
- Enter your license number and PIN (last 4 of your SSN unless you have changed it);
- Answer required questions; and
- Pay $90 reinstatement fee.
NOTE: Following expiration, a broker’s license is reinstated on inactive status. To regain active status, a License Activation / Affiliation form (REC 2.08) also must be submitted.
To reinstate a license expired for 6 months but no more than 2 years
- Successfully complete one 30-hour Postlicensing course (course must be completed within 6 months prior to submitting reinstatement application); and
- Submit a reinstatement application with the $90 application fee and all required documentation, including criminal background report;
-OR-
- Submit a reinstatement application with the $90 application fee and all required documentation, including criminal background report; and
- Pass the National and State sections of license exam.
NOTE: Following expiration, a broker’s license is reinstated on inactive status. To regain active status, a License Activation / Affiliation form (REC 2.08) also must be submitted.
To reinstate a license expired for more than 2 years:
- complete the 75-hour NC Broker Prelicensing course [is this Successfully supposed to be a link? It might be helpful?] ;
- Submit a license application with the $100 original application fee and all required documentation, including criminal background report; and
- Pass the National and State sections of license exam.
NOTE: When a license has been expired for more than two years and is reinstated, brokers are licensed as a provisional broker and are subject to the 90-hour Postlicensing education program. To gain active status, a License Activation/Affiliation form (REC 2.08) also must be submitted.`
For more information, review Commission Rule 58A .0505 or visit the “Reinstate your License” page on the Commission’s website. You may also contact the Commission’s Education & Licensing Division at ls@ncrec.gov or 919-875-3700.
Reminder to Instructors: Reinstate your license today!
Per Commission Rule 58H .0306, Commission approval of instructors expires annually on June 30th. If you are a Commission-approved instructor who failed to renew their instructor approval by June 30, 2024, you have a limited amount of time to reinstate that approval. Similar to expired brokers, instructors have 6 months to reinstate their approval. Therefore, if you want to remain a Commission-approved instructor, then you have until December 31, 2024, to reinstate your instructor approval. If you are unsure of your status as an instructor, log in to the Instructor Dashboard and click on “View My Record.”
In order to reinstate your instructor approval, you must first complete 6 hours of instructor development education (if you have not already). For a list of options to complete this requirement, please review our Guidelines for Instructional Educational Requirement (Form REC 3.78). Once you have completed the required education, you will then need to log in to the Instructor Dashboard, click on the blue Reinstate button in the center of the page, complete the form, and click Submit.
If we do not receive your renewal application by December 31st, you will no longer be able to reinstate your instructor approval. After December 31st, you will need to go through the original instructor approval process including successfully passing the New Instructor Seminar.
Case Study: Competency
FACTS: A broker has practiced residential sales for 10 years. Recently, one of their former clients asked them to act as a property manager for several of their residential properties. The broker is reluctant to act as a property manager because they do not have any experience and/or education in this specialty area of brokerage. However, after much contemplation, the broker and their former client execute a property management agreement.
ISSUE: Is the broker permitted under License Law and Commission Rules to perform property management services? Is the broker competent to act as a property manager?
ANALYSIS: Yes and Maybe. In North Carolina, there is only one type of real estate license for individuals, the broker license. North Carolina’s 75-hour Prelicensing Course educates students on the basic principles of real estate. An individual who has successfully completed that course and who has passed the NC Real Estate License Examination is deemed to have minimal competency to engage in any type of brokerage in North Carolina. Although brokers possess minimal competency, before engaging in any particular type of transaction, brokers should evaluate whether additional knowledge or skills are necessary to adequately represent their clients.
Prior to brokers engaging in any area of brokerage (e.g. residential sales, property management, commercial sales, vacation rental management, historic properties, lakefront properties, and foreclosures, etc.) they should speak with their BIC and evaluate their competency by using the “competence road map.” Essentially, brokers should ask themselves the following questions: (1) Am I authorized by my BIC to engage in this type of transaction, and (2) Do I have the necessary education and training in this type of transaction? If not, can my BIC mentor me or help me find a good mentor?
In the scenario above, the broker should speak with their BIC first to obtain permission to perform property management services. Before granting permission, the BIC should determine whether they are knowledgeable enough in the specialty area of brokerage – in this case, property management – to supervise the transaction. BICs should authorize affiliated brokers to practice only in the areas of brokerage that the BIC can adequately supervise pursuant to Rule 58A .0110.
If the broker does obtain the BIC’s permission, then the broker and the BIC should evaluate the broker’s knowledge and skills to ensure the broker is competent to perform brokerage services and adhere to their fiduciary duties with their client, either on their own, or with guidance from the BIC.
Here, the broker should consider taking additional property management courses prior to conducting these transactions. Brokers can also take continuing education courses that are also dedicated to property management and look for certification and/or accreditation programs for property management specialists.
Remember, although a broker possesses the minimal competency to engage in specialty areas of brokerage upon obtaining a North Carolina real estate license, an inexperienced broker will be held to the same standard as a broker who practices property management transactions regularly in the industry. Therefore, a BIC and the affiliated broker should evaluate the necessary education and experience to conduct a specialty transaction to ensure competency.
RESOURCES:
N.C.G.S. § 93A-6(a)(8), and 93A-6(a)(10)
License Law and Commission Rules: 58A .0110
Articles: 2019-2020 Update Course Section, “Competence of Licensees”